Our Google Business Profile shows in the map pack for "seo fraser valley". That's what the chart for our own business said when I started this series in October, and the reason it shows is worth a minute. The profile is pinned to McCallum Road. When someone in Abbotsford types "seo fraser valley", Google treats that as a local search, draws its three pins from businesses near that person, and ours is near.
Now hand that same geometry to a business that actually serves the whole valley. A furnace company based out on the Mt. Lehman side that does Mission, Chilliwack and Hope. A mobile mechanic who'll drive to Aldergrove. The question I get is "how do I rank in Chilliwack?" and the first answer is: with one profile in Abbotsford, mostly you don't.
Why one profile stays home
The map pack is built around a point on the map. Your profile has one. When someone in Chilliwack searches "furnace repair", Google draws its three pins from the businesses near that person, and a profile pinned to Abbotsford is thirty minutes down Highway 1 from them. There are Chilliwack furnace companies closer. Google shows those. It isn't a judgment about your work; it's geometry.
The service-area setting doesn't override this as much as people hope. Listing Chilliwack as an area you serve tells Google you'll go there, and it stops your profile looking irrelevant to a Chilliwack search. It doesn't move your pin. For a search with plenty of local competition, which "furnace repair chilliwack" has, the local businesses still win the box. Where the service area does help is in thinner categories and smaller towns: if you're the only backflow tester who lists Hope, you can show up in Hope.
I measure this for clients by tracking the same phrases from more than one town, because RankTrack pins the location per check. "Furnace repair" from Abbotsford and "furnace repair" from Chilliwack are two different results pages and get two different lines on the chart.
The three options that work
Set the service area properly. Cheap, do it today, and it's the first thing I'd do regardless. Pick the towns your trucks go to. Not the whole province, which weakens the listing everywhere, and not just Abbotsford if half your jobs are in Mission. This is a setting on the profile, and Google's own guidance for business profiles is at support.google.com/business.
Open a second location, if you really have one. A real address in Chilliwack where someone works, with its own phone number and its own profile, gets its own pin and competes in Chilliwack's map pack on Chilliwack's terms. This works. It also has to be real. A mailbox at a shipping store or a friend's spare office is the kind of thing that gets a profile suspended, and getting one back is slow and boring and I'd rather you didn't need to. If you're running crews out of Chilliwack most days anyway, a small office there is a legitimate business decision that happens to fix the search problem too. If you aren't, it's not.
Write content per town. The organic results don't have the same geometry problem. A page titled "Furnace repair in Chilliwack" that talks about Chilliwack (the neighbourhoods you've worked in, the drive, the older homes with the furnaces from the eighties) can rank for a Chilliwack search even with your pin in Abbotsford, because organic ranking is about what's on the page, not where your office is. One page per town you serve, written like you've been there, which you have. This is the slow option and the one with the longest reach, and it's what the local content in the $199 plan is for: two pieces a month, aimed at the towns and services where the chart says you're missing.
What I'd tell the furnace company
Fix the service area this week. Start tracking the main phrases from Abbotsford and from Chilliwack, so you can see the gap instead of guessing at it; that's $79 a month per location you want measured. Then write, or have us write, the Chilliwack page, and the Mission page, and give them a few months. Only talk about a second profile once there's a real second place.
Valley-wide isn't one ranking. It's three or four towns, each with its own box, and you earn them one at a time.